Showing posts with label Responding is Healthy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Responding is Healthy. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

WLOX Interviews Hood on Health Care

WLOX has this interview with Attorney General Jim Hood over whether he will file suit against Obamacare.



Here is the transcript. Hood says it is difficult and deals with the supremacy clause. He says he and other "attorneys general vehemently protect states rights when the federal government comes in to preempt our authority to use our consumer protection laws."

He says sometimes the commerce clause can be a "stretch" like when it gives congress the right to regulate the growth of marijuana for personal use.

And he says he isn't going to rush into it.
Hood: We're still researching the issue, you know, I mean there are some real complicated constitutional issues. I've sat down with constitutional scholars, law professors to talk about the commerce clause is a complicated issue as well as you're dealing with the supremacy clause of the United States Constitutional and the Tenth Amendment - states rights - we attorneys general vehemently protect states rights when the federal government comes in to preempt our authority to use our consumer protection laws. So I'm familiar with that aspect but the others, you know, people in our office are looking at it and soon we should be able to arrive at a conclusion as to what to do. We're just trying to find if there’s anything that the state has a leg to stand on in filing that suit.

WLOX: Do you think it is constitutional to ask everyone to get health care?

Hood: Well that's the question we're looking at. The body of law though, you know, I don't necessarily agree with it, that the case law of the United States Supreme Court has stated that, you know, that a person who grows marijuana, for example, for personal use in one state, uh, congress has a right to regulate that because they said that affects interstate commerce, because it would be buying it from something else, which seems like a stretch, but that's a law and so we'll have to deal with what the law is.

WLOX: And uhm you know some people may think ‘well it feels like Mr. Hood is stalling. You're just waiting.’ How do you feel about that? You talked about research right?

Hood: Well, you know, if you're going to file a suit against the United States government, you need to be right. You need to know what you'll be filing, you'll be successful at. And so we're going take our time. We're not going to let anybody rush us into making some decision. We're going to make a learned decision. That's what a lawyer's supposed to do. Let's take the emotion and politics out of it and make a decision based upon the dry law.

WLOX: Do you think it’s become more about politics and not about law?

Hood: Well our office is dealing with it from the point of view that it’s strictly the dry law that we're going to look at. We'll make a decsion and we'll do the right thing.

WLOX: One last question, I guess, how long do you think it will take?

Hood: Well, you know, we've had that issue for about two weeks now and so we're we're. You don't normally file a suit within a two week period. You work on it, you work on your complaint, you review it. Florida is about to file an amended complaint. I'd like to see what their allegations are in that amended complaint. So, we get all the information we can and we'll make a decision based on the evidence and the facts.

WLOX: Barbour says he might file one on his own, what do you think about that?

Hood: Well the statute allows him to do so if the attorney general refuses to or neglects to do so.

WLOX: Anything else?

Hood: That's it.

WLOX: Thank you so much.

Friday, March 26, 2010

Barbour: "I swore an oath" to support the Constitution

Governor Haley Barbour sent a letter to Attorney General Jim Hood reaffirming his commitment to challenging Obamacare in court as unconstitutional.
As a statewide elected official, I swore an oath that I would "faithfully support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of Mississippi"...This oath and my own believe that a violation of the Constitution should never go unchecked obligate me to ensure Mississippi challenges the healthcare reform law.

As the Attorneys General of fourteen states have already determined, the healthcare reform law violates the U.S. Constiution...a number of constitutional problems which have already been identified by attorneys and academics across the nation...I intend for Mississippi to join this litigation not later than the date on which the First Amended Complaint is filed by the Attorneys General who States are plaintiffs to the Florida suit. If, by that time, you have determined you wish to represent the state, I would appreciate you and your office's doing so. If you decide otherwise, I will retain outside counsel and provide your office with a copy of the contract for your ratification.
Jim Hood has a lot of baggage going into his 2011 reelection bid. If he refuses to challenge, or refuses to allow Mississippi's Governor to challenge Obamacare in the courts, that would be near the top of the list for any opponent to make an issue.

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Hood Refuses to Authorize Barbour to Sue Obamacare

You can read Attorney General Jim Hood's response to Governor Haley Barbour here.

But the short of it is Hood claims the health care bill is really really hard stuff and will take a long long time to read and figure out and he doesn't know how long, but he is refusing to join with the other states (who apparently were able to figure it out much quicker than him) in filing a lawsuit against it to protect Mississippi.

And lest the Governor decides he wants to do so, Hood makes it clear:
so there will be no misunderstanding with regard to the matters set forth above, you are not authorized by this office to engage or employ counsel, file suit, or intervene in pending litigation at this time while we are completing our review and making our decision whether to file suit
Many attorneys believe Obamacare is clearly unConstitutional. Many other attorneys believe it is clearly permissible under the Constitution. But for Hood...dang, its just really hard stuff and he can't figure it out yet.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Lack of Health Insurance is Not a Terminal Condition

The Mississippi Health Advocacy Program made this claim in a recent Tweet, "over the next 10 years, 4900 Mississippians will die as result of not having health insurance."



Lack of health insurance is not a terminal condition. No one will get a death certificate pronouncing the cause of death "Lack of Health Insurance." Injuries and illness kill people, not the lack of a premium based contract in which you pay a company in order that they will pay certain bills if necessary. Getting health insurance alone does not change behavior, life style, genetics, or life choices.

And the other side of the coin is every Mississippian, EVERY Mississippian who does have health insurance, will still die.

Friday, December 18, 2009

Obamacare drives Mississippi Democratic elected official to the GOP

Democrats should take note of the impact their faith in Obamacare is having on their grassroots and farm team. Another Mississippi Democrat has switched to the Republican Party and he says it was because he is fed up with Obamacare.
The occasion was used to recognize Neshoba County Chancery Clerk Larry McMillan, who announced his intentions to switch to the Republican Party, having been a lifelong Democrat.

Steele joked with McMillan, noting all the big-name state Republicans who came out for the event.

"You really bring them out Larry," Steele said. "It's a great honor that I get to welcome you to the Republican party."

Barbour also welcomed McMillan, saying they were "tickled to have him," and that he's sure when he looks back on it "you'll only wish you'd done it sooner."

In his fifth term, McMillan attributed his switch to being fed up with the Democrat Party's push for health care reform.

McMillan is the 9th county or municipal elected official in Mississippi to switch to the Republican Party this year.
RNC Chairman Michael Steele and Governor Haley Barbour were on hand to welcome McMillan to the Party.